What Is a Child Custody Evaluation in California?

A parent meeting with a child custody evaluator in a Sonoma County office

A child custody evaluation is a court-ordered investigation into your family, conducted by a neutral mental health professional who reports back to the judge. If a court has ordered one in your case, it usually means the dispute could not be resolved at the earlier stages — and that the report, when it arrives, will carry real weight.

These assessments are often called 730 evaluations, after California Evidence Code section 730, the provision allowing a court to appoint its own expert. In a custody case the authority also comes from Family Code section 3111. If you are facing one in Sonoma County, a Santa Rosa child custody lawyer can help you prepare for it and respond to what it produces.

What is a custody evaluation and when is it ordered?

It is an in-depth investigation conducted by a court-appointed mental health professional — typically a licensed psychologist, psychiatrist, licensed marriage and family therapist, or licensed clinical social worker, with specialized forensic training.

In most custody disputes, parents first attend Child Custody Recommending Counseling, Sonoma County’s form of court-connected custody mediation. An evaluation is a further step, ordered when the counselor’s recommendation is not enough to resolve the dispute or when the issues in the case call for deeper investigation.

Courts order evaluations under Family Code § 3111 and Evidence Code § 730 in cases involving:

  • Serious, unresolved allegations of domestic violence or child abuse
  • Unmanaged mental health conditions or substance abuse concerns
  • High-conflict disputes where the parents are deadlocked
  • Resist-refuse dynamics or allegations of parental alienation
  • Proposed out-of-state or long-distance relocations

Who does the evaluator work for?

The court. This is the most important thing to understand about the process, and it is where parents most often go wrong.

A 730 evaluator is a neutral appointed by the judge, not an expert either side has hired. They are not your advocate, and nothing you tell them is being gathered on your behalf. A parent may separately retain their own expert to review the evaluator’s methodology, but that is a different role entirely — and the court-appointed evaluator’s report is the one that lands in front of the judge.

What does the evaluation process involve?

Evaluations follow procedural standards set by California Rules of Court, rule 5.220, and generally include:

  1. Parent interviews. Individual and sometimes joint interviews covering your parenting approach, daily routines, your relationship with your child, and your capacity to co-parent.
  2. Child observation and interviews. Age-appropriate sessions assessing the children’s comfort, emotional state, and relationship with each parent.
  3. Collateral contacts. Interviews with people who know the family — teachers, pediatricians, therapists, daycare providers.
  4. Record review. School records, medical history, police reports, prior court filings, and relevant communications between the parents.
  5. Psychological testing. In some cases, standardized testing of one or both parents.

A word on conduct during the process: evaluators are trained to notice coaching. Attempting to script what your child says, or using sessions to disparage the other parent, tends to register as exactly what it is, and it damages the impression you are trying to make. Your attorney can help you prepare for interviews without crossing that line.

Who pays for a custody evaluation?

The court allocates the cost between the parents, usually in the order appointing the evaluator, and typically based on each parent’s ability to pay — split evenly, divided proportionally, or assigned to one parent.

Expect this to be a significant expense. A private evaluation is among the more costly steps in a family law case, and the allocation is something your attorney can argue about based on each side’s financial disclosures. Where a court-connected evaluator conducts the investigation instead, Family Code section 3112 allows the court to examine a parent’s financial condition and order repayment of the cost.

What happens when the report is finished?

Under Family Code section 3111, the report is filed with the court clerk and served on the parties, their attorneys, and any counsel appointed for the child, at least 10 days before the custody hearing.

That window matters. It is the time you have to read the report closely, identify what is wrong or incomplete in it, and decide with your attorney how to respond before you are in front of a judge.

The report is confidential. Family Code section 3111 limits who may see it, and a disclosure that is reckless or malicious and not in the child’s best interest can draw a monetary sanction — potentially including the other side’s attorney’s fees. Parents sometimes want to share an unfavorable report with family, post about it, or send it to a school. Do not. Ask your attorney what you are permitted to do with it.

How much weight does the report carry?

A great deal, though it does not bind the judge. The court decides custody, not the evaluator.

In practice, judges give substantial weight to a neutral professional’s assessment, because it reflects investigation that competing declarations from two parents cannot provide. The report also shapes settlement negotiations well before any hearing — once it exists, both sides are bargaining in its shadow.

That is precisely why it is not the end of the matter if it goes against you.

What if you disagree with the report?

You can challenge it. An evaluation is evidence, not a verdict, and it is open to the same scrutiny as any other expert opinion.

Approaches include:

  • Retaining your own expert to review the evaluator’s methodology and identify departures from rule 5.220
  • Cross-examining the evaluator at the hearing about gaps, assumptions, or sources they did not consult
  • Presenting evidence and testimony that contradicts specific findings

Challenges succeed on specifics — a collateral contact never interviewed, a record overlooked, a conclusion that does not follow from the evaluator’s own observations. Disagreeing with the overall recommendation, without more, rarely moves a judge.

Talk to a Sonoma County custody attorney

A custody evaluation is one of the most consequential stages a contested custody case can reach, and the preparation that matters happens before the first interview, not after the report arrives. If you are facing a court-ordered evaluation, or you have received a report and need to decide how to respond, we can help.

If your situation has changed since your last order, see our guide on how to modify a custody order in Sonoma County.

Contact Andrew Conway Law PC to discuss your case.

About the Attorney: Andrew Conway

Andrew Conway, family law and criminal defense attorney in Santa Rosa, California

Andrew Conway is a family law and criminal defense attorney at Andrew Conway Law PC in Santa Rosa, representing clients throughout Sonoma County. He has been licensed to practice in California since 2016 and is an active member in good standing of the State Bar of California (#311707).

Experience with these cases. Andrew handles contested custody matters in Sonoma County Superior Court, including high-conflict cases where the court orders a formal evaluation. He has served as court-appointed minor’s counsel, representing a child’s interests in a custody matter — a role that works alongside evaluators and gives him a view of the process from inside it. He began in family law as a certified law clerk at Legal Aid of Sonoma County, representing domestic violence survivors, and received a pro bono award from the Sonoma County Bar Association for that work.

Credentials

  • Licensed: California, since 2016 — State Bar of California #311707, active
  • Education: J.D. and M.L.S., Empire College School of Law (2014); B.A. Sociology, Sonoma State University
  • Recognition: Super Lawyers Rising Stars, Family Law, 2025–2026; Pro Bono Award, Sonoma County Bar Association
  • Practice areas: Family law, criminal defense, and juvenile dependency
  • Languages: English and Spanish — represents Spanish-speaking clients directly, without a third-party interpreter

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Family law statutes and court procedures change; consult a licensed attorney regarding the specifics of your case.